15 Comments
User's avatar
Heather's avatar

Can't see pubs lasting much longer if this carries on. A G&T in my local, trendy East London pub is already almost £8 - for a stingy UK measure of gin barely bigger than a tablespoon, it's absolute joke.

Expand full comment
James Cooray Smith's avatar

Lime Bike regulation is included in the forthcoming English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill. Clauses 18 - 20.

Expand full comment
Joey den Broeder's avatar

Avoiding NI charges has always been the reason behind """optional""" service charges, no? It's just expanding to places where you wouldn't expect them, at much lower rates than restaurants. Give it a few years and you'll be perfectly used to paying 15% service charge on a pint.

Good luck getting them removed. Some servers take it as a personal insult when you ask to remove the service charge. Wonder what the numbers are for people who take the time to get it removed, probably less than 5%?

Expand full comment
worksheet's avatar

If the next government cuts NI back to reasonable levels I imagine this practice will cease

Expand full comment
All Mouth And Trousers's avatar

NI should be scrapped and tax adjusted accordingly. NI has been a lie since at least the 1980s, that money doesn't all go to pay the NHS and pensions.

Expand full comment
William Schneider's avatar

Doubt it; I suspect it’s a one-way street because unless NI and VAT drop to 0, it’s still more tax efficient. It may have been prompted by increasing rates but once they’re avoiding the tax they won’t go back.

Expand full comment
All Mouth And Trousers's avatar

"They said all the money goes to staff via an independent tronc, a technical term for a system used for allocating tips among hospitality staff:"

As someone who worked in a hotel where this was claimed to happen it is a lie. The company will take a share "for administrative costs". In the end the waiters and waitresses just kept the tips and put nothing in the pot.

Expand full comment
Promachos's avatar

When I worked in hospitality years ago, it was commonly known that the only way to make sure a tip went to a specific member of staff was to give it to them in cash. No cash = no real tips for good service, and an increasingly cash-free society is better for companies than employees.

Expand full comment
Caspar J Wilson's avatar

Sounds like another corporate tax loophole that needs to be closed.

Expand full comment
CM's avatar

I love this publication, but reading it depresses me. End times indeed.

Expand full comment
William Schneider's avatar

On the plus side it seems for a good number of issues, a few weeks to months later we get a piece where the appropriate authority actually has taken or is taking action once the spotlight is shone; like the fake charities

Expand full comment
Kaiser Basileus's avatar

Call it what it is - theft. Bc they didn't add any additional product or service.

Expand full comment
Frank c30's avatar

If there’s a tronc in operation then the “troncmaster” is responsible for operating PAYE on payments he/she distributes and for paying deductions to HMRC.

Expand full comment
Mark Mills's avatar

I'd be happy to pay ge tip to reduce the money the government gets to use on spy flights over Gaza

Expand full comment
Charles Pender's avatar

The only adverse issue for me in the service charge would be lack of transparency if the price of the drink is advertised without the service charge (or without “+ voluntary service charge”). But a bigger reason for avoiding these pubs is that are horribly “cashless”. Cue a whole load of transactions on your CC or bank statement that you’ll be hard put to remember or check to know whether they are even genuine - forget the 4%. I’ll avoid these pubs on that ground, not the service charge that helps staff.

Expand full comment